Boston Kitchen Pizza

Open late, but the food and vibe didn’t work for me

Boston Slice Pizza was conveniently located right next to my hostel, so I stopped by late at night during Thanksgiving weekend. I genuinely appreciate that the staff was still open and working hard — that part was great.

But the rest of the experience wasn’t very good. I ordered a chicken slice, and instead of preparing or properly reheating it, they took a cold slice from the shelf and simply placed it in the warmer. It became warm, but the chicken didn’t feel properly cooked and the overall taste wasn’t enjoyable. I ate it only because I was hungry.

The prices also felt a bit high for the quality: a plain cheese slice was around $5, while mushroom or chicken slices were $6.

To add to that, a group of young people inside were extremely loud — likely drunk — and the noise made the atmosphere uncomfortable and disrespectful to others.

Overall, I’m glad they were open late, but the food quality, pricing, and vibe just didn’t make this a place I’d return to.

Ordered Classic Cheeseburger includes fries. Mention what toppings you’d like. Gave generous portion of fries. I thought menu included onion rings but I guess it’s fries OR onion rings. Delicious. Here in Boston for my birthday retreat. Will try the pizza next time.

The pizza here is delicious—thin crust, not too greasy but just greasy enough, with plenty of pepperoni cooked to that perfect crunchy edge. Honestly, one of the better pies I’ve had in a while.

That said, the shop itself could definitely use an upgrade. It’s got that “well-loved but overdue for a refresh” vibe.

⚠️ Heads up about the location: it’s right on Main Street, and if you’re driving, prepare yourself. It took us 20–30 minutes just to get out of traffic. My advice? If you’re in a car, have someone jump out like I did, grab the pizza, and make a quick run back to the car. If you’re on foot, you’ll be fine.

Bottom line: come for the pizza, not the ambiance, and plan your pickup wisely.

Absolutely delicious. Being from out of state I wanted to understand the hype about Boston Pizza and this was phenomenal. Our group of 5 all said this is the best pizza we’ve ever had.

Staff was super friendly and went out of their way to take care of us! You wouldn't expect that in such a small joint. And the pizza slices were huge and yummy! I got Spinach & Garlic.