This place seemed to be a popular spot with the locals so I decided to give it a try. While not the best slice I’ve had, it stopped my rumbling stomach. Maybe it was the slice I chose (chicken, ricotta and pepperoni) but it definitely looked better than it tasted. I left satiated but not satisfied. Not sure if I’d return but if I did, I would probably just get a plain pepperoni slice.
Go for: Substantial selection of high-quality pizza by the slice - like any good pie, you can taste it in the cheese and the crust.
Avoid if: You're claustrophobic.
Something surprising: Each slice is really two slices. You'll be well-fed for less than $10 (as of 2025...)
Reservation needed? No, counter service only. Get in where you fit in.
Overall Experience: 4/5. It's a hole-in-the-wall establishment, but the pizza can hold its own. For anyone visiting Boston, this is a no-nonsense establishment, so don't expect to be doted on. They have lots of different varieties. Seating is limited, so expect to wait for a table sometimes, or eat outside during the summer.
Value for Price: 5
Sanitation: 3
Food Quality: 4
Menu Precision: 5
Service Quality: 3
Timing: 5
Decor: 3
Access: 4
—
5 among the best
4 strong
3 not too bad
2 mediocre
1 never again
The pizza was good, but the service was horrible! Of course, whenever you order pizza you have to order a fresh whole pie straight out of the oven. Otherwise, you’ll be stuck with a slice that has been sitting for who knows how long, which has lost all of its flavour. So yes the pizza was good, but when we asked for a few glasses of water, we had a rude response from the staff and were forced to buy bottled water. Naturally, I recommend that you don’t waste your money at Ernesto’s pizza.
Went there right when they opened, a tasty classic slice. Impressive chew on the crust and very tasty overall. One slice is really two - nothing wrong with that!
Holy cow this place is awesome. The line moves quickly and the pizza is delicious. Have you ever had pickles on pizza? Me neither until I came here. The cheese burger pizza is so freaking cool and whacky and it 100%works. My wife doesn't eat much meat and took multiple bites. I mean special sauce and pickles and lettuce and burger. Oh man. If you have any cravings out there this is the place to fill them. Huge reminder a slice is actually two slices here so be aware. Yummy and we will be back for sure.