Gary's Pizza

Unique, tasty, fairly priced. I live just three blocks from Gary’s and we have many alternative pizza places to choose from. Gary’s is our monster favorite. The large unique Roman style brick pizzas are fabulous with crisp crust, strong bread, generous toppings, and rich flavors. I like how instead of just ordering whole pizzas you can customize the mix of slices to appeal to different tastes. My favorites are mushroom with extra pecorino and a taste of truffles, as well as the good old fashioned pepperoni snd cheese . The focaccia bread is also fabulous with its olives, garlic and dried tomatoes. They are unique in adding final toppings after reheating their already-warm fresh slices just before boxing. It guarantees that they will be hot. I also like how they add different pizzas each week to give you variety. We have used it three times for takeout for Patriots games, impress our guests, and just keep wanting more.

I don’t remember how the pizza tasted in Italy since it has been years, so I didn’t expect this pizza to unlock a memory from that trip. The crust was perfectly crispy and airy, and each slice had a distinct flavor. The salt-cured egg yolk on the Green Asparagus in particular was interesting—there wasn’t much, but the amount that was there added an impactful dimension to the flavor.

My main critique is that the pizza was very salty. It definitely got to be too much after the first slice. I wondered if it was an off batch, but the cookies in the ice cream sandwich were also overwhelmingly salty (the house-made vanilla bean gelato was delicious, though!). I saw a review claiming the pizza to be too sweet, so maybe the feedback had been taken too far in the other direction.

Regardless, 5/5 because it was a pleasant dinner overall, and service was very friendly.

The pizza is delicious with a soft foccacia-like dough, and they load up the pizzas with the toppings. The cookie is great too!

We were so impressed with the service - our delivery order was missing a few slices. When we called, they were so nice about it and made a second delivery (and wouldn't accept a tip for the extra effort!). Huge shout out to Chase for going above and beyond to ensure we enjoyed our rainy evening in. We were already happy with the addition of a pizza option in the area but now we'll be sure to keep coming back with more friends!

Delicious pizza: airy crust, premium toppings, great pairings. Take out only. A bit hot and small inside.

Didn’t know the 1/2 and full size pizzas were made to order so had to wait 20 minutes (thought was going to get the equivalent of the available slices on display).

Take out pizza
The people at the counter did not speak any English and could not answer my question
All in all in the confusion I ended up with an extra slice of pizza 🍕

Now the pizza
I loved it
Not the traditional pizza as the base is like focaccia bread creating a very airy dough
They also made an effort to grate some extra parm cheese on top together with some sauce
$6 per slice