New York Pizza

New York Pizza is a casual slice shop focused on classic New York-style pizza, oversized slices, subs, wings, and late-night convenience. The main appeal is the portion size and accessibility, with large slices that are noticeably bigger than the standard slice you would find at most pizza shops. The setup is simple and practical, making it more of a quick stop for a filling meal than a place you would plan a visit around.

The slices are generous and come with a variety of topping options, from classic cheese to options like buffalo chicken and chicken bacon ranch. The crust has some of the expected thin New York-style qualities, though the execution can vary depending on the slice. Some slices come out hot with a nice balance of sauce, cheese, and crispness, while others can lean softer or heavier with more grease. The subs and other menu items help expand the options beyond pizza, but the main reason to visit is still the oversized slices.

Service can be inconsistent, especially during busier times when wait times stretch longer than expected. The staff experience depends on the visit, but the late-night hours make it a convenient option when other places are closed. The restaurant is more focused on speed and volume rather than creating a polished dining experience.

New York Pizza works best as a late-night meal, quick bite, or when you want a large slice at a reasonable price. It is a convenient neighborhood option, but not necessarily a place to go out of your way for. The big slices and availability are the biggest strengths, while the overall quality lands more in the reliable comfort food category rather than a standout pizza destination.

Service was extremely slow even though it didn’t seem busy. It took them over 30 min to get me my pizza and chicken wings ready. After I waited there for what seemed to be forever, I went home without checking my order. To my surprise, my wings didn’t have any sauce on it which I specifically ordered. The pizza was not cooked thoroughly and extremely soggy and greasy on the bottom. Nothing like a real New York pizza. I called the store to complain but I was placed on hold for over 5 min just to listen to the chatter in the background. After a while I gave up and hung up as no one ever got back in the phone. Just bad customer service and food experience overall! Will never come back here and would recommend not to buy anything here. Not wroth the money nor your time!

I've always liked the chicken parm subs from this establishment but I happened to order a cheese pizza and was truly disappointed. There is too much tomato sauce and the cheese was not melted or evenly distributed. Overall, this pizza seemed undercooked. This has happened to me twice and there won't be a third time. I will stick to chicken parmesan subs until that disappoints me.

Do NOT order from here. I mistakenly thought this was a different place and ordered a simple, small cheese pizza.

What arrived was….almost a pizza? The crust looked like it was play-dough, raw, misshapen, ripped when I tried to take any slice. Cheese was incredibly uneven, some pools of sauce with huge areas uncovered, other areas massive clumps of cheese.

I couldn’t even bring myself to try it, it looked and felt that bad to pick up. Not worth doing that to myself.

Never again.

Imagine: it's midnight as you leave wally's jazz bar. you've had a few beers and at this point anything will hit the spot. you order a pizza with chicken. what you receive? an amalgamation beyond explanation. whether it can be classified as pizza is doubtful. the sole existence of what you're served is adequate proof that god is either not real or not all good. the experience of new york pizza changed not only my perspective on the establishment, but permanently shattered my opinion of italian cuisine as a whole.